The post “Ask HN: What intelligent forums exist outside of HN?” sparked a lively discussion among Hacker News users on where else one could find thoughtful, well-moderated discussions beyond the storming tech currents of HN. Participants shared a range of suggestions—some pointing to communities known for their quality discussion, others advocating for niche and specialized forums where ideas flow without the noise. Popular alternatives like Lobsters were frequently mentioned for its developer-centric community, while other suggestions ranged from subreddits to forums focused on rational inquiry and tech debates. The thread illustrates that while Hacker News has its unique blend of insightful dialogue, there’s a whole ecosystem of platforms each with its distinct flavor of intelligence and community spirit.

Key Points:

• The HN post sought recommendations for intelligent discussion forums outside of Hacker News.
• Lobsters was commonly recommended as a high-quality, developer-focused alternative.
• Other alternatives, including select Reddit communities and specialized discussion sites, were mentioned.
• The conversation also delved into what defines “intelligent” discourse and the challenges of forum moderation.
• The thread reflects a shared desire for communities that balance thoughtful discussion with engaging content.

Joke: Why did the forum moderator bring a ladder to the discussion? Because he heard the conversation was reaching new heights—just like his favorite posts on Lobsters!
Link to Article