In this fascinating examination of Elon Musk's latest productivity initiative, The New Yorker lays bare the inherent contradictions and challenges of managing knowledge-work in today's fast-paced environments. Musk's directive for federal employees to send a simple "5-bullet" email outlining their weekly accomplishments was meant to demonstrate a Silicon Valley-style efficiency, yet it quickly unraveled amid bureaucratic pushback and clarifications that downgraded the original mandate. The article traces the roots of modern management theories—from Peter Drucker's "management by objectives" to Andy Grove’s and John Doerr’s development of O.K.R.s—and highlights how even these celebrated systems have struggled to yield the breakthrough productivity Musk envisions. As Musk’s approach at Twitter and elsewhere has shown, “a thirty-seven-word e-mail is unlikely to do the trick,” exposing the gap between tech sector mythology and the complex reality of measuring knowledge-work.

Key Points:

• Musk’s Directive: Elon Musk ordered federal employees to report their weekly achievements via a simple email, which he later downplayed by stating, “The passing grade is literally just ‘Can you send an email with words that make any sense at all?’”
• Bureaucratic Resistance: High-ranking officials, including FBI Director Kash Patel and National Intelligence Director Tulsi Gabbard, advised employees to ignore the directive, highlighting the tension between Musk's approach and established government protocols.
• Historical Context: The article revisits management theories from Peter Drucker’s mid-century ideas on objective-based management to the evolution of O.K.R.s by Andy Grove and John Doerr, which have become central to productivity strategies at companies like Google, Intel, and Hewlett-Packard.
• Modern Challenges: Despite their theoretical appeal, both M.B.O. and O.K.R. methods have been criticized for being easily manipulated and failing to accurately capture true employee productivity, as seen in Musk's erratic management style at Twitter.
• The Productivity Paradox: The piece underscores that the fundamental question—"What did you do last week?"—remains unsolved, illustrating the complexity of measuring productivity in knowledge-driven work environments.

This blend of managerial history and contemporary corporate drama makes the case that achieving real productivity in complex organizations is far more elusive than a catchy Silicon Valley mantra.
Link to Article