The barefoot running craze of 2010 was a wild, fascinating moment in fitness history—part science, part evangelism, and a whole lot of shoeless optimism. It all started as rebellion against the bulky “clown shoes” dominating running stores in the early 2000s, and caught fire with the release of Christopher McDougall’s bestselling book Born to Run. Suddenly, running forums were ablaze with barefoot truths, Vibram 5 Fingers were flying off shelves, and minimalist movement felt like a revolution pushing back against decades of cushioned orthodoxy. But the revolution didn’t quite stick the landing. While barefoot running sparked important conversations about natural form and overengineered shoes, it also resulted in a surge of injuries and a cautionary tale about going all-in on “natural” without proper adaptation. Still, the movement reshaped the running world—for better or worse—and left a lasting impact on the shoes we lace up today.

Key Points:

• The barefoot running boom began in earnest around 2009, catalyzed by Christopher McDougall’s book Born to Run, which spotlighted the ultra-distance-running Tarahumara tribe of Mexico and their minimalist sandals called huaraches.

• Minimalist shoes like the Nike Free (released in 2004) and Vibram FiveFingers (2006) exploded in popularity as runners chased the idea of improved performance via a “natural” gait.

• At the peak of the craze in 2010, the movement was fiercely dogmatic. “Heel striking was evil; barefoot running was the natural and therefore ‘correct’ way to run.”

• However, many barefoot adopters were novice runners who jumped in too fast, leading to increased injury rates including Achilles tendinitis and metatarsal stress fractures.

• The appeal to nature fallacy—“it’s better because it’s natural”—undermined serious discourse about proper form and individualized approaches to running.

• Studies offered mixed results: Some found benefits, but others reported higher injury risks, especially during transition periods.

• While the barefoot trend faded, it permanently changed the industry: modern running shoes embraced lighter, more flexible designs and shifted away from motion-control-heavy models.

• The minimalist revolution led to a new wave of maximalist shoes from brands like HOKA, which combined deep cushioning with minimalist-inspired geometry like lower drop and reduced stability features.

• Recommended products from that era and its legacy include:

  • Vibram FiveFingers (minimalist)
  • Nike Free (transitional/minimalist)
  • Modern options: HOKA Clifton, Saucony Kinvara, and Altra Escalante (zero-drop)

• The barefoot moment “may have been a short-lived trend,” writes Jon K., “but it sparked crucial conversations about running health and led to significant advancements in running footwear.”

Whether you're team barefoot or just happy to have more shoe options that don’t look and feel like bricks, the fallout from 2010’s hysteria is still reshaping your runs today.
Link to Article