🎙️ Episode Summary: “They’re Brainwashed—Not Me, Right?”

In an era marked by social media echo chambers and deep political polarization, the once-dusty Cold War term “brainwashing” is making a big comeback—but are we using it to understand others, or to excuse ourselves? The New Yorker’s ambitious essay “It’s Always the Other Side That’s Been Brainwashed” dives deep into the messy psychology, history, and philosophy of thought control. From Cold War reeducation camps to the modern influencer economy, the article explores how belief is shaped by coercion, persuasion, trauma, and tribal identity. Harvard historian Rebecca Lemov argues there’s more going on than metaphor—brainwashing, she claims, is “not rare but common.” But here’s the twist: accusing someone of being brainwashed may say more about us than them. Instead of uncovering manipulation, it may simply reflect our disbelief that others could sincerely hold views we find outrageous.

📌 Key Takeaways:

• 🧠 Brainwashing is back: Once considered a kitschy Cold War relic, “brainwashing” is seeing renewed relevance in modern discourse—thanks to social media, partisan media bubbles, and mass polarization.

• 📚 Books to Note: Several recent works have tackled the topic seriously:

  • Brainwashed: A New History of Thought Control by Daniel Pick
  • Dark Persuasion: A History of Brainwashing from Pavlov to Social Media by Joel E. Dimsdale
  • The Instability of Truth by Rebecca Lemov

• 🗣️ Lemov Speaks Up: Unlike others, Lemov doesn’t hedge: “What we call brainwashing is not rare but common.” She introduces the idea of “coercive persuasion”—a blend of influence and force that reshapes belief.

• 📖 Classic Case Study: U.S. soldier Morris Wills underwent a long, trauma-laden psychological reeducation in a Chinese POW camp, eventually becoming “totally convinced” of Communist ideology. It wasn't electrodes—it was introspection and manipulation.

• 💣 Patty Hearst Example: Her kidnapping and conversion into a radical soldier spotlight the legal system’s discomfort with blaming criminal action on brainwashing. The courts didn’t buy it.

• ⚖️ Legal Quagmire: Brainwashing creates a double-bind in court: if it works, the belief feels genuine, nullifying coercion; if it doesn't, there's no basis for a defense of duress.

• 📲 Social Media Echo Chamber: Dimsdale and Lemov both note how online tools amplify influence. One Facebook insider admitted experiments seemed like “mind control,” and that really isn’t far off.

• 🔮 The Manipulation Myth: Are we all subject to invisible nudges? As sociologist Zeynep Tufekci warns, Big Tech “quietly [models] our personality… and effectively [shapes] our ideas, desires and dreams.”

• 🚨 Not Just Trauma: Lemov links brainwashing to trauma, but applying that to cyberspace or modern ideological shifts is tricky. Not every TikTok rabbit hole compares to a POW camp.

• 🧩 Tribal Beliefs: Many modern beliefs aren’t just about truth—they’re identity markers. Like passwords (or shibboleths) to belong to a group. As the article notes, “persuasion is what we do; brainwashing is what they do.”

• 🧗 Popper’s Warning: Philosophical legend Karl Popper reminds us not to assume “truth is manifest.” Sometimes people aren’t victims of manipulation—they’re just on a different epistemic journey.

⚖️ Final Thought: Maybe, instead of seeing those who disagree as dupes needing rescue, we should ditch our savior complexes. After all, assuming someone has been brainwashed might be the ultimate form of intellectual laziness.

🎧 Stay skeptical, stay kind—and maybe re-read Locke before your next Twitter takedown.
Link to Article